| Rank
| Title
| Lifetime Gross | Max Theaters | Opening | Open Th | Release Date | Distributor
|
|---|
| 1 | Cop Land | $44,862,187 | 2,233 | $13,510,482 | 2,233 | Aug 15, 1997 | Miramax |
| 2 | Just Friends | $32,619,671 | 2,505 | $9,275,000 | 2,505 | Nov 23, 2005 | New Line Cinema |
| 3 | Lean on Me | $31,906,454 | 1,107 | $5,032,605 | 894 | Mar 3, 1989 | Warner Bros. |
| 4 | Confessions of a Teenage Drama Queen | $29,331,068 | 2,503 | $9,350,572 | 2,503 | Feb 20, 2004 | Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures |
| 5 | Garden State | $26,782,316 | 813 | $201,115 | 9 | Jul 28, 2004 | - |
| 6 | Jersey Girl | $25,268,157 | 1,821 | $8,300,000 | 1,520 | Mar 26, 2004 | Miramax |
| 7 | Harold & Kumar Go to White Castle | $18,250,550 | 2,163 | $5,200,000 | 2,135 | Jul 30, 2004 | New Line Cinema |
| 8 | Atlantic City | $12,729,675 | - | - | - | Apr 3, 1981 | Paramount Pictures |
| 9 | Freedomland | $12,512,886 | 2,361 | $5,833,562 | 2,361 | Feb 17, 2006 | Revolution Studios |
| 10 | Win Win | $10,179,275 | 388 | $150,362 | 5 | Mar 18, 2011 | - |
| 11 | Nothing But Trouble | $8,479,793 | 1,671 | $3,966,240 | 1,671 | Feb 15, 1991 | Warner Bros. |
| 12 | Running Scared | $6,855,137 | 1,611 | $3,075,000 | 1,611 | Feb 24, 2006 | New Line Cinema |
| 13 | The Station Agent | $5,739,376 | 198 | $57,785 | 3 | Oct 3, 2003 | Miramax |
| 14 | Bogus | $4,357,406 | 1,209 | $1,895,593 | 1,134 | Sep 6, 1996 | Warner Bros. |
| 15 | New Jersey Drive | $3,565,508 | 210 | $1,395,028 | 210 | Apr 21, 1995 | Gramercy Pictures (I) |
| 16 | Clerks | $3,151,130 | 96 | $31,665 | 2 | Oct 19, 1994 | Miramax |
| 17 | Happiness | $2,982,011 | 60 | $130,303 | 6 | Oct 16, 1998 | Good Machine |
| 18 | Mallrats | $2,122,561 | 852 | $1,153,838 | 852 | Oct 20, 1995 | Gramercy Pictures (I) |
| 19 | Baby It's You | $1,867,792 | 30 | $12,420 | 1 | Mar 4, 1983 | Paramount Pictures |
| 20 | Find Me Guilty | $1,173,643 | 439 | $628,000 | 439 | Mar 17, 2006 | Yari Film Group Releasing |
| 21 | Storytelling | $921,445 | 40 | $73,688 | 4 | Jan 25, 2002 | Fine Line Features |
| 22 | Palookaville | $365,284 | 24 | - | 7 | Oct 25, 1996 | The Samuel Goldwyn Company |
| 23 | Whatever | $307,037 | - | - | - | Jul 10, 1998 | Sony Pictures Classics |
| 24 | Restaurant | $75,232 | 24 | $11,750 | 24 | Jan 28, 2000 | - |
| 25 | Jersey Guy | $4,268 | 3 | $2,324 | 3 | Apr 25, 2003 | Castle Hill Productions |
