| Rank
| Title
| Lifetime Gross | Max Theaters | Opening | Open Th | Release Date | Distributor
|
|---|
| 1 | Wicked | $285,659,270 | 3,888 | $112,508,890 | 3,888 | Nov 22, 2024 | Universal Pictures |
| 2 | A Few Good Men | $141,340,178 | 2,201 | $15,517,468 | 1,925 | Dec 11, 1992 | Columbia Pictures |
| 3 | Fences | $57,682,904 | 2,368 | $129,462 | 4 | Dec 16, 2016 | Paramount Pictures |
| 4 | Biloxi Blues | $43,184,798 | 1,330 | $7,093,325 | 1,239 | Mar 25, 1988 | Universal Pictures |
| 5 | Closer | $33,987,757 | 1,098 | $7,707,972 | 476 | Dec 3, 2004 | Sony Pictures Releasing |
| 6 | Romy and Michele's High School Reunion | $29,235,353 | 1,607 | $7,429,406 | 1,602 | Apr 25, 1997 | Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures |
| 7 | Cats | $27,166,770 | 3,380 | $6,619,870 | 3,380 | Dec 20, 2019 | Universal Pictures |
| 8 | Other People's Money | $25,682,090 | 1,249 | $5,012,332 | 1,246 | Oct 18, 1991 | Warner Bros. |
| 9 | Judy | $24,313,888 | 1,627 | $2,916,548 | 461 | Sep 27, 2019 | Roadside Attractions |
| 10 | Oscar | $23,562,716 | 1,391 | $5,091,027 | 1,388 | Apr 26, 1991 | Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures |
| 11 | Frankie and Johnny | $22,773,535 | 1,150 | $4,768,177 | 1,150 | Oct 11, 1991 | Paramount Pictures |
| 12 | Prelude to a Kiss | $20,006,730 | 1,248 | $5,273,395 | 1,247 | Jul 10, 1992 | Twentieth Century Fox |
| 13 | An Ideal Husband | $18,542,974 | 772 | $192,802 | 10 | Jun 18, 1999 | Miramax |
| 14 | Born Yesterday | $17,952,857 | 1,301 | $5,911,343 | 1,297 | Mar 26, 1993 | Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures |
| 15 | Marvin's Room | $12,803,305 | 1,158 | $57,739 | 6 | Dec 20, 1996 | Miramax |
| 16 | Brighton Beach Memoirs | $11,957,943 | 778 | $2,580,750 | 775 | Dec 26, 1986 | Universal Pictures |
| 17 | Glengarry Glen Ross | $10,725,228 | 417 | $2,104,402 | 416 | Oct 2, 1992 | New Line Cinema |
| 18 | Lost in Yonkers | $9,285,189 | 1,190 | $3,002,150 | 1,190 | May 14, 1993 | Columbia Pictures |
| 19 | The Importance of Being Earnest | $8,384,929 | 216 | $500,447 | 38 | May 17, 2002 | Miramax |
| 20 | Whose Life Is It Anyway? | $8,206,145 | 615 | - | - | Dec 2, 1981 | Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer (MGM) |
| 21 | The Crucible | $7,343,114 | 344 | $62,995 | 1 | Nov 29, 1996 | Twentieth Century Fox |
| 22 | Six Degrees of Separation | $6,405,918 | 201 | $53,058 | 2 | Dec 10, 1993 | Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer (MGM) |
| 23 | To Gillian on Her 37th Birthday | $4,189,233 | 807 | $77,725 | 5 | Oct 18, 1996 | Sony Pictures Releasing |
| 24 | The Winslow Boy | $3,957,934 | 141 | $80,553 | 6 | Apr 30, 1999 | Sony Pictures Classics |
| 25 | Jeffrey | $3,487,767 | 63 | $185,909 | 10 | Aug 4, 1995 | Orion Classics |
| 26 | Talk Radio | $3,468,572 | 653 | $80,547 | 6 | Dec 23, 1988 | Universal Pictures |
| 27 | Love! Valour! Compassion! | $2,977,807 | - | - | - | May 16, 1997 | Fine Line Features |
| 28 | Noises Off... | $2,280,148 | 451 | $981,452 | 451 | Mar 20, 1992 | Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures |
| 29 | Hurlyburly | $1,798,862 | 84 | $164,826 | 16 | Dec 25, 1998 | Fine Line Features |
| 30 | M. Butterfly | $1,498,795 | 120 | $57,280 | 3 | Oct 1, 1993 | Warner Bros. |
| 31 | Simpatico | $929,606 | 256 | - | - | Jan 28, 2000 | Fine Line Features |
| 32 | The Winter Guest | $870,290 | 21 | $20,533 | 3 | Dec 25, 1997 | Fine Line Features |
| 33 | The Sum of Us | $766,464 | 30 | $38,479 | 5 | Mar 10, 1995 | The Samuel Goldwyn Company |
| 34 | Rosencrantz & Guildenstern Are Dead | $739,104 | 18 | $24,004 | 2 | Feb 8, 1991 | Cinecom Pictures |
| 35 | The Shape of Things | $735,992 | 60 | $173,246 | 40 | May 9, 2003 | Focus Features |
| 36 | American Buffalo | $665,450 | 73 | $164,109 | 29 | Sep 13, 1996 | The Samuel Goldwyn Company |
| 37 | SubUrbia | $656,747 | 24 | $69,365 | 16 | Feb 7, 1997 | Sony Pictures Classics |
| 38 | The House of Yes | $626,057 | 54 | $63,266 | 4 | Oct 10, 1997 | Miramax |
| 39 | Tape | $490,475 | 35 | $28,424 | 7 | Nov 2, 2001 | Lionsgate |
| 40 | The Browning Version | $487,391 | 24 | $48,719 | 12 | Oct 12, 1994 | Paramount Pictures |
| 41 | The Cherry Orchard | $135,280 | 3 | - | - | Feb 22, 2002 | Kino International |
| 42 | Oleanna | $124,693 | 22 | $25,316 | 15 | Nov 4, 1994 | The Samuel Goldwyn Company |
| 43 | The War at Home | $44,722 | 6 | $15,040 | 4 | Nov 22, 1996 | Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures |
| 44 | The Substance of Fire | $31,638 | 11 | $56,211 | 11 | Mar 14, 1997 | Miramax |
| 45 | The 24th Day | $14,460 | 1 | $2,001 | 1 | May 14, 2004 | Screen Media Films |
